Seeing that the whole issue with the Christmas Village has been settled, I think it is appropriate for a fully retrospective commentary on what has to be some of the most ridiculous crap in the political correctness/religious nonsense category for this year. I'm not sure if this whole issue went national or not, but for those who don't know Philadelphia has a Christmas Village set up by our City Hall. It's located on a 1970s soulless concrete hell known as Dilworth Plaza. So the city rents the space out to a business that sets up a German style Christmas village that sells Christmas related stuff as well as completely unrelated touristy garbage. But besides that it's kinda nice (although made out of cheap particleboard) and looks pretty at night.
 |
| That concrete is so 70s Berlin. |
|
So the whole flap about the Christmas Village is that it's called Christmas. Somebody complained and our masculine and forthright Mayor Nutter decided that in the spirit of political correctness that he would courageously remove Christmas from the sign and dub the site the Holiday Village. After legitimate complaints of blatant PC nonsense,
coupled with not so legit religious indignation and accusations of THE WAR ON CHRISTMAS STRIKES AGAIN the steadfast Mayor Nutter decided that the sign shall be put back, PC be damned! At least the union boys who put the thing up and down would be employed for a week or however long it takes them to do simple tasks.
What kind of complaints did the Mayor receive to prompt this? Apparently a story about a little Jewish girl complaining to her father that, "Dad, why don't we have a village?" Assuming that the story is true, a good father would have rebuked the little girl, saying "No daughter, it says Christmas Village not Christian Village. Because if
that was the case he could have said, "We do have a village, it's called New York City". Lame jokes aside, this was an utterly stupid anecdote justifying an even more stupid decision.
Now I'm all for it being called Christmas Village, because that's what it is. Yet I am an atheist. "What gives, all you atheists hate religion and want to eat the baby Jesus." Shocking, I know, but I don't care about Christmas. It's sufficiently secular these days and it is part of American culture to the point where it seems okay for a Christmas themed festival to be hosted on public land leased from the city. We need more festivals, obviously not overtly religious, but still. I just like celebrating. Especially Christmas. Food, gifts, and alcohol - what's could be better?
Now just a week after this whole issue I decided to get a haircut. I've been getting haircuts from the same guy for as long as I can remember and I've always enjoyed thoughtful conversations with the man. I don't remember it ever being political, but we talked about science and sci-fi all the time. This time was no different, we started about the arsenic-based life which we both found fascinating and talked about how there has to be life out there that is utterly incomprehensible to us. The conversation shifted to cosmology, and to Stephen Hawking. I said something about how I respect the man but people hang on his every where. I said that it doesn't matter whether or not the man thought there was a god. It's just one guy's opinion on a subject of which there is no experts. However, there was dissonance in the room. I was saying that I think it's silly to care what one person thinks about a vague concept of "God" because there isn't any evidence for such a being therefore I don't really care period. He, assuming appropriately given my Catholic upbringing, thought that I was coming more of less from a "who are we to question the mind of god" sort of place.
But I wasn't. I hinted at my irreligious nature, which was met with unusual silence. I know the guy is open minded but I didn't know how he would take a revelation of my atheism. I really don't share it with people unless I know them better because saying I'm an atheist outside of certain circles is still not always advisable, even in a (supposedly) liberal city like Philadelphia. So I didn't say the A-word.
Then the topic of the Christmas Village came up. I said it was ridiculous non-issue borne out of political correctness. Which it is, but this guys thinking, "Yeah, this kid's alright, he's on my page." He then says something along the line of, "Well I mean we're a Christian nation and that's what it is. People should respect that or get out."
 |
| My reaction. |
So I'm confused here, is he talking about immigrants? I asked, "What do you mean by 'get out'? Who are we talking about?" He said (keep in mind these aren't exact quotes), "You know the Muslims."
OKAY WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT!?!?! I wanted to say.
But I didn't. I said, "What Muslims?" "You know, the ones that work at city hall." "You mean the ones who converted because their boyfriend did in prison (this phenomenon will be examined in a later post) who also work at city hall? They're not even devout, I've heard those types talk about getting drunk. They wouldn't care about Christmas, they still probably believe in Jesus." "Exactly."
I never felt that disappointment before. You know,when you realize that a family member who claims that they used to go out and jetski all the time when they were kids is actually just relaying their dreams as truth because they used to watch the boys go jetski but never went out with them and decided to live vicariously through lies told to children? Well this was ten times as bad as that. The realization that a man that I respected, who held respectable beliefs regarding science and had good taste in sci-fi was full of shit when it came to politics and religion.
But that wasn't the end of the conversation. He said that he expected that sort of complaint from an atheist. That was the tipping point. I said, "I'm an atheist, and I don't care." He wasn't expecting that. He then started to ask me what I thought about ten commandments and religious figures built into the architecture, and whether or not I thought that stuff should be defaced from buildings. I shared my opinions while trying to demonstrate the "Christian nation" comment was untrue and the whole bizarre Muslim comment wasn't relevant. I came looking for a haircut. Not for a debate. Needless to say my next one should be interesting.